A state charges residents $30 and nonresidents $225 for a license to hunt elk for sport. A nonresident hunter sued, claiming the fee differential violates the Privileges and Immunities Clause of Article IV. Is the hunter likely to prevail?
Pick a letter: the verdict follows the last option, and the reasoning under all four opens.
-
Reasoning for A
Why not A. A higher price for a recreational license does not stop or penalize anyone's movement between states, so the right to travel is not engaged by this fee. -
Reasoning for B
Why B is right. Article IV protects only privileges basic to the nation as a single union, such as earning a living; sport hunting is recreation, so the state may charge nonresidents more. -
Reasoning for C
Why not C. States may not charge nonresidents more for a license to earn a living, such as a commercial fishing license, without close justification, so a blanket rule for every license is wrong. -
Reasoning for D
Why not D. The justification inquiry is reached only after the activity is shown to be a protected fundamental privilege, and elk hunting for sport does not clear that first step.
The rules behind it: Constitutional Law